Priced Before the Trophy
McGonigle and Stewart win Rookie of the Year, and the red rookies were already above last year's ceiling
Allen Hamric
November 11, 2026
Inside the Vault
The sports card newsletter for collectors who want real intel, not hype.
Issue #30 · November 11, 2026 · newsletter.dugoutvault.app
🔒 Vault Trivia — Veterans Day Edition
Since 1987 the Rookie of the Year Award has carried the name of the man who won the very first one, and who served as an Army officer before he ever played a big league game. Who is he? Scroll to the bottom for the answer.
Allen's Note
Today is Veterans Day. Thank you to everyone who has served, and to the families who held things together at home while they did.
Monday night the Baseball Writers named Kevin McGonigle the American League Rookie of the Year and Sal Stewart the National League winner. McGonigle took 28 of 30 first-place votes. Stewart took 20, with Carson Benge getting seven and JJ Wetherholt three. They are both in this issue, and the short version is that the card market paid for the trophy before the vote.
The rest of the big awards land this week. Cy Young is announced Wednesday night and MVP on Thursday night, both at 7 p.m. Eastern on MLB Network. Here are the finalists, with Kalshi's prices as of Wednesday morning.
Award | Finalists | Announced | Kalshi |
|---|---|---|---|
AL Cy Young | Cease (TOR), Messick (CLE), Schlittler (NYY) | Wed 11/11 | Schlittler 100% |
NL Cy Young | Misiorowski (MIL), Sale (ATL), Sánchez (PHI) | Wed 11/11 | Misiorowski 100% |
AL MVP | Alvarez (HOU), Caminero (TB), Witt (KC) | Thu 11/12 | Alvarez 100% |
NL MVP | Crow-Armstrong (CHC), Ohtani (LAD), Turang (MIL) | Thu 11/12 | Crow-Armstrong 100% |
Finalists and dates: MLB.com. Kalshi prices read Nov. 11 from the Cy Young board (updated 9:23 a.m. ET) and the MVP board (updated 7:35 a.m. ET). Every other contract I could see on those boards sat at the 1-cent floor.
Kalshi's 100% says the market thinks the races are over. The ballots were cast before the playoffs and nobody outside the BBWAA has seen them. Kalshi had McGonigle at 99% and Stewart at 93% on Monday morning, and Stewart still needed 20 of 30 first-place votes to get there. I trust the favorites. I would not call any of them locks.
Pat Murphy finished first in the Manager of the Year for the National League, beating Braves manager Walt Weiss. Weiss received 7 first place votes to 20 for the Milwaukee Brewers manager, who took home the award for the third consecutive year. Chicago White Sox Will Venable won the AL Manager of the Year award after leading the Southside Sox to a +24 win improvement from 2025.
Chris Sale is the only Braves finalist for the NL Cy Young. He had a 2.16 ERA, second in the league, and 200 strikeouts in 162 2/3 innings. Jacob Misiorowski had a 1.80 ERA and 252 strikeouts. Kalshi gives Sale a penny.
Market Pulse
What Last Year's Winners Say About This Year's Cards
The market got to McGonigle and Stewart before the voters did. Both red rookies have been selling well above last year's winners for weeks. Here are all four side by side, using the real sold listings and not the price guide's headline number.
Red rookie | Median sale | Sales | Dates |
|---|---|---|---|
Nick Kurtz (2025 AL winner) | $40.29 | 30 | Aug 19 to Nov 6 |
Drake Baldwin (2025 NL winner) | $22.99 | 30 | Aug 3 to Oct 21 |
Sal Stewart (2026 NL winner) | $61.00 | 17 | Sep 8 to Oct 20 |
Kevin McGonigle (2026 AL winner) | $68.00 | 27 | Oct 26 to Nov 9 |
Source: SportsCardsPro sold-listing logs, read Nov. 9, 2026. Medians are mine, computed from individual sales after removing listings that are not the red rookie (see below). Kurtz and Baldwin are the 2025 Bowman Chrome Red Rookie Redemption cards.
Last year's winners are the ceiling check. A year after his award, Kurtz's red rookie sells for about $40 raw and Baldwin's for about $23. Both guide prices have slid since I checked in September, Kurtz from $44.96 to $38.00 and Baldwin from $23.63 to $21.21. Stewart and McGonigle sold roughly 50 and 70 percent above Kurtz's median before anyone knew the vote.
That matches what Kalshi was saying. When the market is 93% sure of a winner, the last 7% is all that is left to buy. Two caveats on the sample. Stewart's real-card log is only 17 sales and stops October 20, so his number is softer than McGonigle's. McGonigle's log runs through Nov. 9, so most of it predates the news.
The patient play: let the post-announcement sales print before you spend anything. A trophy has not turned into a price floor for either 2025 winner. I will pull both logs again for Saturday's issue and show you where they settled.
The Card Worth Knowing
Kevin McGonigle
SS/3B · Detroit Tigers · Age 22 · 2026 AL Rookie of the Year
2026 Bowman Chrome #6 Red Rookie Variation
The red-logo rookie short print. Not numbered, not an autograph.
Median sale (27 sales) | First-place votes | bWAR, led the AL |
|---|---|---|
$68 | 28 of 30 | 7.1 |
McGonigle played most of the year at 21, hit .278/.376/.430 with 18 home runs, 72 RBI and 12 steals, and made the All-Star team. The Tigers had already signed him to eight years and $150 million before the vote. He is the first Tigers player to win the award since Michael Fulmer in 2016 and the first Tigers infielder since Lou Whitaker in 1978.
His red rookie is new to the conversation. In early September he had no 2026 red rookie, because he was still carried as a prospect in the Bowman set. His Bowman Chrome base card arrived with the September release, and the red variation came with it. A Bowman Chrome red rookie is a different card from the red Topps Chrome /5s, so do not let a seller blur the two.
Sal Stewart
IF · Cincinnati Reds · 2026 NL Rookie of the Year
2026 Bowman #6 Red Rookie Variation
Filed under 2026 Bowman on SportsCardsPro. Sellers call it Red RC, Red Badge, Red Shield or Red Logo, and many titles say Bowman Chrome.
Median sale (17 sales) | First-place votes | Home runs, 162 games |
|---|---|---|
$61 | 20 of 30 | 32 |
Stewart played all 162 games, hit .263/.330/.457 with 32 home runs, 112 RBI and 15 steals, and beat Benge and Wetherholt in a vote that was not close. The card is the more interesting data problem of the two.
Two Pages, Two Prices
SportsCardsPro files Stewart's red rookie on two separate pages. One says $58.54 raw and $261.24 for a PSA 10. The other says $34.31 raw and $102.50 for a PSA 10. Same card.
The $34.31 page shows 30 logged sales, and 13 of them sold between 25 cents and $30. Those are base Stewart cards filed under the red page. The 17 sales that are the actual red rookie ran from $49.99 to $80, with a median of $61. The other page's log stops September 12 and still carries July sales at $11 to $20, from before anyone cared about the card. Neither page's PSA 10 number deserves trust.
McGonigle's page is cleaner. Two sales in his log are the BCP-145 prospect card and one is a Mega Box variation at $51. I dropped all three and the median stayed at $68 either way. His PSA 10 is listed at $344.29, but the page logs zero PSA 10 sales, so that number is a formula and not a price. The same site lists a McGonigle "Red Refractor #6 /5" at $66, a dollar off the variation. His BCP-145 Red Lava /5 prospect card is listed at $800 on the same site, so a $66 numbered red is variation sales wearing a numbered card's name. I did not use it. The valuation guide covers how to read a sold log.
Both cards are redemptions. Buy the redeemed card, not an unredeemed redemption, because those carry expiration and fulfillment risk. Search every name sellers use, and check the McGonigle sold listings and Stewart sold listings before you pay. If you buy raw, put it in a sleeve and toploader the day it arrives.
What to Watch: The first 20 sales after Monday night. McGonigle sat at a $68 median and Stewart at $61 before the vote. Also watch December 1, when the CBA expires. The labor primer covers what a work stoppage has meant for offseason card demand.
What's Dropping
NOV 11 · 2026 Topps Museum Collection
One eight-card pack per box with an autograph and an autographed relic in it, per Cardlines. The date slid from Oct. 7. Topps sold out its Sept. 8 pre-order at $409.99 a box, and the retailer asking prices I found run $599.99 to $774.95, so the box costs 46 to 89 percent more than Topps charged unless you caught the drop. Those are asking prices, not sold prices. One calendar lists Nov. 12.
PREMIUM
NOV 18 · 2026 Topps Pro Debut
A 200-card minor league base set, six packs of 24 cards per box and about four autographs per box. Presale asking prices run from $179.94 to $249.95 depending on the shop. For prospect hunters who want the first card of the next class.
RELEASE DAY
NOV 25 · 2026 Topps Gilded Collection
Calendars show Nov. 25, but Topps has not posted a product page yet, per Cardlines. Do not assume last year's configuration or guaranteed hits until it does.
DATE UNCONFIRMED
DEC 9 · 2026 Topps Chrome Update
Pre-orders were set to open Nov. 2 and McGonigle is on the checklist. The only street date I found is Dec. 9, on one calendar, with presale from $344.99, so treat the date as pending.
PRE-ORDER
Dates cross-checked Nov. 9, 2026 against Cardlines, Cardsmiths, Dave and Adam's and retailer listings at Giant Sports Cards. Topps.com was not checkable from my tools, so every date here is secondhand and can move. Museum Collection box sold prices on eBay.
Hit Reply
Two questions this week.
First, Rookie of the Year red rookies. Do you buy before the announcement, when the market is guessing, or after, when everyone knows? Tell me what you did with McGonigle and Stewart, and what you wish you had done.
Second, the schedule. I am sending a Wednesday issue so the awards preview lands before the votes do, and a Saturday issue to cover how they came out. Does a midweek send work for you, or would you rather keep it to Saturdays?
Hit reply. It comes straight to me and I read every one.
🔓 Vault Trivia — Answer
Jackie Robinson
Robinson was drafted in April 1942, commissioned a second lieutenant on Jan. 28, 1943, and honorably discharged on Nov. 4, 1944. He won the first Rookie of the Year Award in 1947, and the award was renamed for him in 1987, the 40th anniversary of his debut. Thank you to every veteran today.
Inside the Vault · Published by Dugout Vault · Sent by Allen Hamric · hello@dugoutvault.app
