Cancelled Certs
A $963K truck burglary outside PSA, what's actually inside Topps Holiday, and the Rays slugger the World Series could reprice
Allen Hamric
October 24, 2026
Inside the Vault
The sports card newsletter for collectors who want real intel, not hype.
Issue #27 · October 24, 2026 · newsletter.dugoutvault.app
🔒 Vault Trivia: Milwaukee's Last October
Neither the Brewers nor the Rays has ever won a World Series. Milwaukee's only other trip was 1982, when its shortstop won AL MVP. Name him, and the year of his Topps rookie card. Scroll to the bottom for the answer.
Allen's Note
On Oct. 13, someone broke the lock on a FedEx truck parked near PSA's grading center in Santa Ana, Calif., while the driver was away for 60 to 90 minutes. They took two full pallets of about 100 packages each, plus roughly 50 more off a third. Every box was a finished order headed home to a collector. PSA told police the two full pallets were worth about $963,000, and the final number isn't set until the rest gets scanned (The Athletic, Oct. 19; CBS Los Angeles). No arrests and nothing recovered as of Monday.
PSA's response is the part I know best, because it's my day job. Deactivating a cert number works like cancelling a stolen debit card: the plastic still exists and still looks perfect, but the system declines it. PSA has sent those numbers to its marketplace partners, which pushes thieves toward cracking slabs and selling raw. So for a while, be picky about any high-dollar raw card that looks like it just came out of a case. Affected customers get fair market value up to the insured value they picked at submission. SKY-B's 104-card order was insured up to $156,000. Set your declared value honestly.
Sending cards in this winter? Our new Grading Tracker has every grader's live prices, plus PSA's backlog: 7.2 million cards as of Oct. 20, down from 8.2 million two weeks earlier (PSA backlog tracker).
Market Pulse
Topps Holiday hit shelves Wednesday, and the hits got thinner. SlabSquatch Analytics ran the per-box math off the published odds the same morning, and it's the best breakdown of this product you'll find. The product holds about 113.7 million cards. Autos fell 19% from last year to 9,699. Relics went from 309,682 to 2,375, a 99% cut. That budget moved into Chrome, up 204% to 885,897 cards, and more than 60% of those are unnumbered base Chrome.
Format | Price | Per Chrome | Per numbered card | Per quality hit |
|---|---|---|---|---|
Mega (100 cards) | $30 | $28.68 | $73.17 | $206.13 |
Advent Calendar | $60 | $30.40 | $230.77 | $484.14 |
Tin (59 cards) | $15 | None | $375.00 | $3,091.14 |
Source: SlabSquatch Analytics, "2026 Topps Holiday MLB Deep Dive," Oct. 21, 2026. Retail: Mega $29.99, three-tin box $44.99, Advent $59.99 (Checklist Insider).
Read across that table and the Mega is still the best way to rip Holiday, but it's a worse box than last year. A Mega that used to give you a real shot at a relic now mostly hands you a base Chrome, and an auto shows up about once every 59 boxes. The Advent Calendar is the one format that got better, with two Plaid Chrome Refractors in every calendar, and $484 per quality hit is still a bad deal. Tins are the worst buy on the shelf: no Chrome, no autos, no relics. The only reason to pick one up is Hidden Elf short prints, which fall about 1 in 18 tins compared to 1 in 200 Mega packs.
None of this is scarce, either. Topps printed more than 570,000 Megas and 662,400 tins. Holiday is a gift and a fun Saturday morning with your kids. It isn't a box to hold.
The patient play. Buy Megas to rip, skip tins unless you're chasing Hidden Elfs, and buy the singles you want in January. A lot of Christmas-morning parallels hit eBay the last week of December. Full checklist and odds: 2026 Topps Holiday checklist · Mega boxes on Amazon · Mega sold prices on eBay.
The Card Worth Knowing
Junior Caminero
3B · Tampa Bay Rays · Age 23 · Two-time All-Star · MLB debut Sept. 23, 2023
2023 Bowman Chrome Prospect Autographs #CPA-JCR (1st Bowman auto)
Budget entry: 2024 Topps Chrome #213 RC. About $106 in PSA 10 (median of 19 sales, Jul. 24–Oct. 22, SportsCardsPro).
42 HR 2026 regular season | $956 Avg PSA 10 auto, 36 sales, 3 mo. | −2.4% 3-month trend, same card |
Caminero has hit 87 home runs in the last two seasons: 45 in 2025, then 42 this year with a .276/.360/.524 line and 5.7 WAR (Baseball Reference). Only three players in baseball hit more homers in 2026. He's 23, and he plays in a market that national TV mostly ignores.
His October was ugly until it wasn't. He went 3-for-10 against the Yankees and 4-for-20 with 11 strikeouts through the first five ALCS games, chasing half the four-seamers Cleveland threw him out of the zone. Then in Game 6 he hit a two-run homer off Guardians closer Cade Smith, off the left-field foul pole, to send Tampa to the World Series. He took 38.66 seconds to round the bases, the second-slowest undisputed trot of the Statcast era (MLB.com; MLB.com).
The card market has barely noticed any of this. His 1st Bowman auto in PSA 10 sold 36 times in the last three months, averaging $955.81, all between $778.80 and $1,150. The last sale was $1,000 on Oct. 19, the night of the homer. Over the full window the price moved 2.4% down (Card Ladder, accessed Oct. 21). The cheaper card already moved: his 2024 Topps Chrome RC in PSA 10 went from about $62 in June to around $106 since late July, so the base card priced in the 42 homers while the auto still hasn't. The ceiling is real: a Red Refractor version of that auto in PSA 10 sold for $43,920 in April (SI Collectibles).
Card | Recent sales |
|---|---|
2023 Bowman Chrome Auto #CPA-JCR, PSA 10 | $779–$1,150, avg $956 (n=36, Jul. 21–Oct. 21) |
2024 Topps Chrome #213 RC, PSA 10 | $85–$130, avg $110, median $106 (n=19, Jul. 24–Oct. 22) |
Sources: Card Ladder (auto), accessed Oct. 21, 2026. SportsCardsPro sold listings (Chrome RC, all 19 titles checked as base #213 PSA 10), accessed Oct. 23, 2026. Auto sold listings on eBay · Chrome RC sold listings.
This is a different setup from Bazzana last week. Bazzana's auto was sliding while his team won. Caminero's held flat through a 42-homer season and a rough ALCS, which tells me the floor around $950 is real. Thirty-six sales in a tight range is buyers and sellers agreeing on a price, and the World Series is the first time most of the country will watch him for a week straight.
The clock matters too. Caminero isn't a free agent, so he has no winter signing to move his cards. Once the Series ends, the next catalyst is spring training, and Kalshi gives a new labor deal before Dec. 2 a 6% chance (our Lockout Tracker). If you want him, the next two weeks are the window. I'd rather own the auto under $1,000 before a big Series game than chase it after one.
What to Watch. The high fastball. In the regular season he hit .368 and slugged .882 on elevated fastballs. In the ALCS he swung under 71% of the four-seamers he went after. Milwaukee will pitch him upstairs all week. If he catches up to it, the slump talk is over and $1,000 looks cheap. If he doesn't, wait for December. How we read comps: how to value a sports card.
What's Dropping
New on the site this month: checklist and odds pages for Holiday, Cosmic Chrome, Museum Collection, Pro Debut, Allen & Ginter and Bowman Chrome Sapphire. Dates below update daily on our release calendar.
OCT 21 · 2026 Topps Holiday
Out now. Mega $29.99, three-tin box $44.99, Advent Calendar $59.99. See Market Pulse for the per-box math. For kids, stocking stuffers and Hidden Elf hunters. Check retail here.
OUT NOW
OCT 26 · 2026 Topps Gilded Collection
Pre-order opens on topps.com. Topps hasn't posted much detail yet. We'll cover it once the configuration is out.
PRE-ORDER
OCT 28 · 2026 Topps Five Star
Six encased cards per hobby box, about five numbered on-card autos. For most people this is a product to buy a break spot in, not a box. New to breaks? Start with What Is a Card Break?
PREMIUM
NOV 2 · 2026 Topps Chrome Update
Pre-order opens on topps.com. Release is expected mid-November but not announced. The Chrome version of this month's Update rookie class.
PRE-ORDER
NOV 4 · 2026 Topps Cosmic Chrome
Hobby is 20 packs of four, sold out on topps.com. Planetary Pursuits is the named chase. For collectors who buy on looks. Checklist and odds.
RELEASE DAY
NOV 11 · 2026 Topps Museum Collection
One eight-card pack with an on-card auto, an auto relic and a relic. Premium hit chasers only. Checklist and odds.
PREMIUM
NOV 18 · 2026 Topps Pro Debut
Release day, after pre-orders opened Oct. 19. Minor leaguers in minor league uniforms, for prospect collectors who like a name before the Bowman crowd does. Checklist.
RELEASE DAY
Sources: topps.com release calendar via dugoutvault.app/release-calendar (updated Oct. 21); Cardsmiths Topps calendar; Five Star, Cosmic Chrome and Museum details as published in Issue #26.
Hit Reply
Two questions this week.
First: does the PSA theft change how you send cards in? Are you still mailing, dropping off at a show, or holding everything until spring? And if you've ever had a package go missing, tell me how the claim went.
Second: was the cost-per-hit table for Holiday useful? I can build one for every winter release if you'd actually use it before buying.
Hit reply. It comes straight to me and I read every one.
🔓 Vault Trivia: Answer
Robin Yount, 1975
Yount won the 1982 AL MVP as the Brewers' shortstop, and Milwaukee lost that World Series to the Cardinals in seven. His rookie card is 1975 Topps #223, the same set as George Brett's rookie (#228). He won a second MVP in 1989 as a center fielder (Beckett).
Inside the Vault · Published by Dugout Vault · Sent by Allen Hamric · hello@dugoutvault.app
