Every PSA slab carries a cert number, and that number is the card's paper trail. Run it before you pay for any graded card, every time. It's free, it takes about a minute, and it catches the one problem you can't see by holding the slab.
That got real this month. On October 13, someone broke into a FedEx truck parked near PSA's grading facility in Santa Ana, California, while the driver was away for 60 to 90 minutes. Police say roughly 250 packages of graded return orders were taken, sports and Pokémon both, and they put the value of two of the three pallets at about $963,000. As of October 20, police hadn't announced an arrest or any recovered cards.
PSA deactivated the cert numbers on the stolen cards and alerted the major marketplaces. Those slabs still exist. Somebody has them. They just don't check out anymore.
Think of it like a cancelled credit card
When a bank cancels a stolen card, the plastic doesn't change. It still has the logo, the chip, the name on the front. It looks fine in your hand. Then you run it and it gets declined.
A deactivated cert works the same way. The slab, the label and the card inside all look normal. The lookup is where it fails.
The 60-second check
1. Find the cert number
It's printed on the front of the PSA label, next to the barcode. If you're buying online, ask the seller for a clear, straight-on photo of the label. If you can't read the number, don't buy yet.
2. Run it through PSA
Type the number in at psacard.com/cert, or scan the label with the PSA app.
3. Match every detail
Player, year, set, card number, parallel and grade. If the cert page has images of the card, compare them to the seller's photos: centering, corners, any print marks. One mismatch is enough to walk away.
PSA hasn't said publicly what a deactivated cert shows when you look it up. Treat any of these as a no: no result, an error, or a record that doesn't line up with the card in front of you.
Step three matters more than people think. Counterfeiters have copied real cert numbers onto fake slabs for years. A clean lookup tells you the number is real. Matching the images tells you the slab in front of you is the card PSA graded.
Red flags
The seller won't show the label. Blurry photo, label cropped out, “trust me, it's legit.” Pass.
Numbered cards with no history. A /25 or /10 listed for the first time in late October, with no prior sales, deserves a second look. Boston Card Hunter (@BosCardHunter) has been crowdsourcing a list of stolen numbered cards. It's self-reported and PSA doesn't verify it, but it's worth a search on high-end numbered cards.
Freshly cracked raw cards. This is the hole in the system. A deactivated cert does nothing once the card is out of the slab. A thief can sell it raw or send it to another grader. Be careful with a seller who suddenly has several high-end raw cards and no good reason they came out of their slabs.
A price well under recent sales. If a PSA 10 is listed far below what the last few sold for, there's a reason. Pull the comps and find out what it is.
“Recovery” offers. If your order was on the truck and a stranger DMs you offering to track down your cards for a fee, that's a scam. Deal with PSA and the police directly.
If a cert comes back bad
Don't buy it. If you already did, don't resell it. Screenshot the listing, the messages and your payment, then open a case with the marketplace or your payment method. Contact PSA customer service through psacard.com and give them the cert number.
If your own order was on that truck, PSA says it is contacting affected customers directly and will pay fair market value, up to the insured value you chose when you submitted. Find that email and check what value you picked.
Protect your own submissions
That insured-value cap should change how you submit. Plenty of collectors send cards in over the winter, so now is a good time to tighten things up. (If you're still deciding when to send, here's how we think about grading timing.) Nothing you do fixes a truck getting broken into outside the grader. The rest of the trip is yours to protect.
Declare honestly
Declared value drives which PSA service level you qualify for, so there's a pull to keep it low and save on fees. The bill for that comes due when something goes wrong, because PSA's payout is capped at what you declared. Insuring a $2,000 card at $500 is like insuring your house for a quarter of what it's worth. Fine until the one day it isn't.
Document everything before it ships
Photograph the front and back of every card, keep a copy of the submission form, and write down serial numbers. That record gets a claim paid faster, and it's what lets a tracker match a numbered card if it ever turns up.
Don't let the return sit on a porch
If your return ships FedEx, have it held at a FedEx location or be home to sign for it. A box of slabs on a doorstep is the easiest theft there is.
Free · Weekly
Inside the Vault
Grading news, market moves and stories like this one, every Saturday morning. It's free.
Subscribe Free →Make it a habit
Run the cert on every slab you buy, including the $40 ones and the ones from sellers you trust. It costs nothing, and the one time it comes back wrong pays for every time it didn't.
For practice, pull up a few PSA-graded baseball cards under $50 on eBay and run the certs before you ever buy. It takes a few minutes and you'll know exactly what a clean record looks like.